Classic Combo
$74.95
Party tray cheese pizza, 50 jumbo wings, and 12 breadsticks.
“The sweet sauce pizza is out of this world. I make the drive from Lancaster to Lockport just to grab a couple of slices.”

Cheese pizza, deli subs, jumbo wings and burritos anchor the fast food at Papa Leo's Pizzeria in New York, available for pickup.
Order onlineClassic Combo
$74.95
Party tray cheese pizza, 50 jumbo wings, and 12 breadsticks.
“The sweet sauce pizza is out of this world. I make the drive from Lancaster to Lockport just to grab a couple of slices.”
X-Large Pizza (16")
$20.65
16-inch cheese pizza with a choice of traditional or sweet sauce.
“Papa Leo's will always be my go-to for sweet sauce. They're my favorite. We always try to stop by when we're in the area. Also, the cup n char pepperoni is the best! Also, their price for an xl pizza can't be beat.”
Party Pizza (30 Slices)
$33.03
Cheese party-tray pizza is cut into 30 slices with your sauce choice.
“Ordered one of the pizza specials they had going on for the month and was very impressed with it. Huge thanks to Scott for steering me towards that deal, the large pizza was cheaper than the medium”
Hawaiian Pizza
$21.66+
Pizza topped with ham and pineapple; choose a size.
“Food was really good. The manager working, Scott, was very friendly and made my pizza to perfection!”
Steak & Cheese Sub
$13.44+
Grilled steak and melted cheese fill a sub roll.
“Subs are great! Service is just as good! The cashier, Jaymis, was very polite and helpful. Definitely recommend.”
Stinger Sub
$13.44+
Steak and chicken fingers fill this sub, with a choice of sauce flavor.
“I was unsure on what I wanted when I was ordering but Jaymis helped by recommending a stinger sub which was very good”
Ham Sub
$12.37+
Deli ham, lettuce, tomato, and onion on a Costanzo roll with chosen cheese.
“Jaymis Taylor made very good subs and was very nice”
Grilled Chicken Sub
$13.44+
Grilled chicken on a sub roll with your choice of cheese.
“Stoped for lunch had Grilled chicken sub. Very good”
10 Wings
$16.51
Ten wings with blue cheese and carrots; choose traditional or boneless.
“Bright and clean. Friendly staff and perfect wings!”
Wing Wednesday
$7.90+
Wings cost 79¢ each with a 10-wing minimum on Wednesdays.
Finger Dinner (5)
$12.99
Five chicken fingers come with fries, blue cheese, and hot sauce.
“Papa Leo’s is a great restaurant with kind staff. I love the chicken fingers. I would recommend it”
50 Wings
$59.80
Fifty jumbo wings served with blue cheese and carrots, with sauce choices.
“The chicken wings were cooked perfectly and was delivered 20 minutes earlier than estimated time. Delivery driver was friendly as well.”
Beef Burrito
$10.31
A soft-shell burrito is filled with zesty beef, cheese, and vegetables.
“I have been coming to this restaurant for quite some time & I always have a great experience! Even if I take a couple weeks off, they still remember me, know my name! All the The staff here very polite and kind whenever I enter! Espically Emma and Damien! These two are amazing and great at what they do with their work ethic, knowledge, and strong personality that makes it worthwhile to come back again and again! (Also, for a "pizza place" they make one of my favorite burritos!)”
Chicken Finger Burrito
$10.78
A soft-shell burrito filled with chicken fingers, cheese, and vegetables.
Papa Leo's Pizzeria serves fast food spanning cheese pizzas, deli subs and burgers on kaiser rolls. You can also get soft-shell burritos filled with zesty meat, cheese and vegetables.
Steak & Cheese Sub pairs grilled steak with melted cheese on a fresh sub roll. Onion Rings are served with Boom Boom Sauce, and Chicken Quesadilla comes with both salsa and sour cream.
Visit or order from Papa Leo's Pizzeria in New York for pickup, dine-in or delivery. With 2 Slices & a Pop, you get two slices and a drink all day, every day, with flavors such as Cherry Coke or Loganberry.
Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.