American Food in New York

Grilled burgers, deli subs and sauced wings anchor American food at Papa Leo's Pizzeria in New York, with pickup available for your meal.

Order online

Wings

Wing Wednesday

$7.90+

Choose traditional or boneless wings in a selected sauce flavor.

10 Wings

$16.51

Ten jumbo wings with your chosen flavor, blue cheese, and carrots.

20 Wings

$28.89

Twenty wings come with blue cheese and carrots; choose a sauce flavor.

50 Wings

$59.80

Fifty wings served with blue cheese and carrots; choose a style and flavor.

Chicken

Family Feast (10)

$24.99

Ten chicken fingers come with fries, blue cheese, and hot sauce.

Finger Dinner (5)

$12.99

Five chicken fingers, fries, and a required choice of wing flavor.

Subs

All Day Lunch Special

$12.99

Lunch special includes one 8-inch sub of your choice and a fountain drink.

Assorted Sub

$12.37+

Capicola, bologna, and salami fill a sub with your choice of cheese.

Burgers

Cheeseburger

$12.37

A cheeseburger with melted white American cheese comes with fries.

Hamburger

$11.37

A hamburger served with fries, with toppings available to customize.

Mushroom Swiss Burger

$12.67

Angus burger with sautéed mushrooms, melted Swiss, and fries.

Pickle Ranch Burger

$12.37

An Angus burger with ranch-coated fried pickles, pickle slices, and fries.

Salads

Buffalo Chicken Salad

$13.97

Salad with mozzarella, vegetables, and chicken fingers tossed in sauce.

Grilled Chicken Salad

$13.97

Grilled chicken, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, and onion in a salad.

Seafood

Breaded Shrimp

$12.37

Breaded shrimp with optional fries, coleslaw, and sauce selections.

Fish Fry

$18.87

Battered Icelandic haddock with fries, coleslaw, tartar sauce, and ketchup.

Fries

Buffalo Chicken Fries

$7.22

French fries tossed in hot sauce are served with blue cheese.

Cajun French Fries

$7.22

Cajun-seasoned French fries served with ranch dressing.

Cheddar Bacon Fries

$9.25

Fries topped with cheddar and bacon, served with ranch dressing.

French Fries

$5.15

French fries are served with ketchup, and extra sauces are available.

Made with Care at Papa Leo's Pizzeria

Papa Leo's Pizzeria serves American food with grilled burgers, deli meats on sub rolls and wings with sauce choices. You can also get chicken salads with mozzarella and battered haddock with cole slaw.

Steak & Cheese Sub pairs grilled steak with melted cheese; Royal Sub combines fried capicola and Italian sausage. Mozzarella Sticks come with marinara, while Cajun French Fries include ranch dressing.

Visit us in New York for pickup, dine-in or delivery. Your Stoner Burrito packs a burger patty, steak, two slices of bacon and fried onions; All Day Lunch Special pairs an 8-inch sub with a fountain drink.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for american food throughout the New York area. Order your american food online for convenient pickup or delivery.