Stinger Sub
$13.44+
Hot sub with steak and chicken fingers; choose size, cheese, and flavor.
“I was unsure on what I wanted when I was ordering but Jaymis helped by recommending a stinger sub which was very good”

Burgers, subs, and sauced wings anchor American food at Papa Leo's Pizzeria in New York, with pickup available for your meal.
Order onlineStinger Sub
$13.44+
Hot sub with steak and chicken fingers; choose size, cheese, and flavor.
“I was unsure on what I wanted when I was ordering but Jaymis helped by recommending a stinger sub which was very good”
Cheeseburger Sub
$13.44+
A grilled cheeseburger on a fresh Costanzo sub roll.
“Very polite on the phone when placing the order. Very pleasant, kind and welcoming when picking up order. Food was made exactly as ordered. Izzy did a great job, subs were delicious! Thank you!”
Chicken Club Sub
$13.44+
Grilled chicken, bacon, lettuce, and tomato on a fresh sub roll.
Assorted Sub
$12.37+
Capicola, bologna, and salami tucked into a sub roll with chosen cheese.
10 Wings
$16.51
Ten wings with your choice of sauce, blue cheese, and carrots.
“Delicious pizza and wings!”
Classic Combo
$74.95
A party-tray pizza, 50 jumbo Buffalo wings, and 12 sauced breadsticks.
Wing Wednesday
$7.90+
On Wednesdays, wings cost 79¢ each with a 10-wing minimum.
20 Wings
$28.89
20 jumbo wings with blue cheese and carrots; choose style and sauce.
Cheeseburger
$12.37
Cheeseburger on a Costanzo’s Kaiser roll, served with French fries.
Pickle Ranch Burger
$12.37
A pickle ranch burger on a Costanzo’s Kaiser roll, served with fries.
Hamburger
$11.37
A hamburger on a Costanzo’s Kaiser roll, served with fries.
Mushroom Swiss Burger
$12.67
A mushroom Swiss burger on a Costanzo Kaiser roll with fries.
Papa Leo's Pizzeria serves American food with burgers on Kaiser rolls, deli subs with sliced meats, and jumbo wings with sauce choices. You can also get cheese pizza paired with breadsticks and sauce.
Royal Sub pairs fried capicola with Italian sausage, while Stinger Sub combines steak and chicken finger. Fried Pickles come with ranch, and Mozzarella Sticks are served with marinara sauce.
Visit Papa Leo's Pizzeria in New York for pickup, dine-in, or delivery. Fish Fry comes with 12 oz of battered Icelandic haddock over French fries, plus cole slaw, tartar sauce, and ketchup.
Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.